Difference between AWS ECS

AWS ECS (Elastic Container Service) and AWS EKS (Elastic Kubernetes Service) are both container orchestration services provided by Amazon Web Services (AWS). While they share similarities in that they both manage containerized applications, they differ significantly in terms of underlying technologies, use cases, and the level of complexity they handle.

AWS ECS (Elastic Container Service):

AWS ECS is AWS’s proprietary, fully managed container orchestration service. It is tightly integrated with the AWS ecosystem and allows you to run and manage Docker containers on a cluster of Amazon EC2 instances or AWS Fargate, without requiring deep knowledge of container orchestration.

Key Features

Proprietary Service

ECS is AWS-specific, meaning it is designed to work seamlessly with other AWS services such as IAM, ELB, and CloudWatch.

Simplified Management:

ECS abstracts away much of the complexity of managing containers, providing a more straightforward approach to deploying and managing containerized applications.

AWS Fargate:

ECS can use AWS Fargate, a serverless compute engine, to run containers without the need to manage the underlying EC2 instances.

Less Learning Curve:

ECS is easier to learn and use for developers who are already familiar with the AWS ecosystem, as it requires less configuration and setup.

AWS EKS (Elastic Kubernetes Service):

AWS EKS is a managed Kubernetes service that allows you to run Kubernetes on AWS without having to manage the Kubernetes control plane. Kubernetes is an open-source container orchestration platform that is widely used across various cloud providers and on-premises environments.

Key Features AWS ECS

Kubernetes Compatibility: EKS provides a fully compliant Kubernetes environment, allowing you to use standard Kubernetes tools and APIs. This makes it ideal for users who want to leverage Kubernetes’ extensive features and flexibility.

Multi-Cloud and Hybrid Support: Since Kubernetes is an open-source platform, EKS supports hybrid cloud and multi-cloud architectures, allowing you to run workloads on-premises or on other cloud providers.

Advanced Orchestration: Kubernetes offers more sophisticated orchestration features, such as custom scheduling, namespaces, and advanced networking configurations.

Steeper Learning Curve: EKS requires a deeper understanding of Kubernetes, which has a steeper learning curve compared to ECS. However, it provides more flexibility and control over the orchestration of containers.

Key Differences AWS ECS

1. Complexity and Learning Curve:

• ECS: Easier to use, especially for developers already familiar with AWS. Suitable for simpler use cases where deep container orchestration capabilities are not required.
• EKS: Requires more in-depth knowledge of Kubernetes but offers more advanced orchestration features and flexibility.

2. Management:

• ECS: Managed entirely by AWS, with seamless integration into AWS services. ECS abstracts away much of the complexity associated with running containers.
• EKS: Managed Kubernetes service that requires users to handle more of the orchestration details, although AWS manages the control plane.

3. Portability:

•   ECS: Tied closely to AWS; less portable across cloud providers.
•   EKS: Kubernetes is open-source and can run on multiple environments, making it more portable across different cloud providers and on-premises infrastructure.

4. Use Cases:

•   ECS: Ideal for AWS-centric applications where simplicity and deep AWS integration are priorities.
•   EKS: Suitable for applications that require advanced Kubernetes features, multi-cloud or hybrid cloud strategies, or where Kubernetes expertise is already available.

Java Example:
Here’s how you might approach deploying a simple Java Spring Boot application using ECS and EKS.

ECS Example:

Assume you have a Spring Boot application packaged as a Docker image.

1. Dockerfile:
   ```dockerfile
   FROM openjdk:11-jre-slim
   COPY target/myapp.jar /usr/src/myapp/myapp.jar
   WORKDIR /usr/src/myapp
   CMD ["java", "-jar", "myapp.jar"]
   ```

2. Deploy to ECS:
   - Create ECS Cluster: Use AWS Management Console or AWS CLI to create an ECS cluster.
   - Task Definition: Define a task that specifies the Docker image and resource allocation.
   - Service: Create a service to deploy and manage the application on the ECS cluster.

EKS Example:

Assume the same Spring Boot application is packaged as a Docker image.

1. Dockerfile: The same Dockerfile can be used as shown above.

2. Kubernetes Deployment YAML for EKS:
   ```yaml
   apiVersion: apps/v1
   kind: Deployment
   metadata:
     name: myapp-deployment
   spec:
     replicas: 2
     selector:
       matchLabels:
         app: myapp
     template:
       metadata:
         labels:
           app: myapp
       spec:
         containers:
         - name: myapp-container
           image: my-docker-repo/myapp:latest
           ports:
           - containerPort: 8080
   ```

3. Deploy to EKS:
   - Create EKS Cluster: Use AWS Management Console, AWS CLI, or `eksctl` to create an EKS cluster.
   - Apply Deployment: Use `kubectl apply -f deployment.yaml` to deploy the application to EKS.

Homepage

Readmore